possibilistic knowledge base
Benferhat
Interval-based possibilistic logic is a flexible setting extending standard possibilistic logic such that each logical expression is associated with a sub-interval of [0,1]. This paper focuses on the fundamental issue of conditioning in the interval-based possibilistic setting. The first part of the paper first proposes a set of natural properties that an interval-based conditioning operator should satisfy. We then give a natural and safe definition for conditioning an interval-based possibility distribution. This definition is based on applying standard min-based or product-based conditioning on the set of all associated compatible possibility distributions. We analyze the obtained posterior distributions and provide a precise characterization of lower and upper endpoints of the intervals associated with interpretations. The second part of the paper provides an equivalent syntactic computation of interval-based conditioning when interval-based distributions are compactly encoded by means of interval-based possibilistic knowledge bases. We show that interval-based conditioning is achieved without extra computational cost comparing to conditioning standard possibilistic knowledge bases.
Compatible-Based Conditioning in Interval-Based Possibilistic Logic
Benferhat, Salem (Artois University) | Levray, Amélie (Artois University) | Tabia, Karim (Artois University) | Kreinovich, Vladik ( University of Texas at El Paso )
Interval-based possibilistic logic is a flexible setting extending standard possibilistic logic such that each logical expression is associated with a sub-interval of [0,1]. This paper focuses on the fundamental issue of conditioning in the interval-based possibilistic setting. The first part of the paper first proposes a set of natural properties that an interval-based conditioning operator should satisfy. We then give a natural and safe definition for conditioning an interval-based possibility distribution. This definition is based on applying standard min-based or product-based conditioning on the set of all associated compatible possibility distributions. We analyze the obtained posterior distributions and provide a precise characterization of lower and upper endpoints of the intervals associated with interpretations. The second part of the paper provides an equivalent syntactic computation of interval-based conditioning when interval-based distributions are compactly encoded by means of interval-based possibilistic knowledge bases. We show that interval-based conditioning is achieved without extra computational cost comparing to conditioning standard possibilistic knowledge bases.
- North America > United States > Texas > El Paso County > El Paso (0.04)
- Europe > Spain > Catalonia > Barcelona Province > Barcelona (0.04)
- Europe > France > Hauts-de-France > Nord > Lille (0.04)
- (2 more...)
Possibilistic decreasing persistence
Driankov, Dimiter, Lang, Jerome
A key issue in the handling of temporal data is the treatment of persistence; in most approaches it consists in inferring defeasible confusions by extrapolating from the actual knowledge of the history of the world; we propose here a gradual modelling of persistence, following the idea that persistence is decreasing (the further we are from the last time point where a fluent is known to be true, the less certainly true the fluent is); it is based on possibility theory, which has strong relations with other well-known ordering-based approaches to nonmonotonic reasoning. We compare our approach with Dean and Kanazawa's probabilistic projection. We give a formal modelling of the decreasing persistence problem. Lastly, we show how to infer nonmonotonic conclusions using the principle of decreasing persistence.
- Asia > Japan > Honshū > Chūbu > Ishikawa Prefecture > Kanazawa (0.25)
- Europe > Sweden > Östergötland County > Linköping (0.04)
- Europe > United Kingdom > England > Oxfordshire > Oxford (0.04)
- Europe > France > Occitanie > Haute-Garonne > Toulouse (0.04)
Merging Uncertain Knowledge Bases in a Possibilistic Logic Framework
Benferhat, Salem, Sossai, Claudio
This paper addresses the problem of merging uncertain information in the framework of possibilistic logic. It presents several syntactic combination rules to merge possibilistic knowledge bases, provided by different sources, into a new possibilistic knowledge base. These combination rules are first described at the meta-level outside the language of possibilistic logic. Next, an extension of possibilistic logic, where the combination rules are inside the language, is proposed. A proof system in a sequent form, which is sound and complete with respect to the possibilistic logic semantics, is given.
- North America > United States > New York (0.04)
- Europe > Netherlands > North Holland > Amsterdam (0.04)
- Europe > Italy (0.04)
- Europe > France > Occitanie > Haute-Garonne > Toulouse (0.04)
Possibilistic logic bases and possibilistic graphs
Benferhat, Salem, Dubois, Didier, Garcia, Laurent, Prade, Henri
Possibilistic logic bases and possibilistic graphs are two different frameworks of interest for representing knowledge. The former stratifies the pieces of knowledge (expressed by logical formulas) according to their level of certainty, while the latter exhibits relationships between variables. The two types of representations are semantically equivalent when they lead to the same possibility distribution (which rank-orders the possible interpretations). A possibility distribution can be decomposed using a chain rule which may be based on two different kinds of conditioning which exist in possibility theory (one based on product in a numerical setting, one based on minimum operation in a qualitative setting). These two types of conditioning induce two kinds of possibilistic graphs. In both cases, a translation of these graphs into possibilistic bases is provided. The converse translation from a possibilistic knowledge base into a min-based graph is also described.
- Europe > France > Occitanie > Haute-Garonne > Toulouse (0.04)
- Europe > United Kingdom > England > Oxfordshire > Oxford (0.04)
- Europe > Spain > Andalusia > Granada Province > Granada (0.04)
- Europe > Netherlands > South Holland > Dordrecht (0.04)
Graphical readings of possibilistic logic bases
Benferhat, Salem, Dubois, Didier, Kaci, Souhila, Prade, Henri
Possibility theory offers either a qualitive, or a numerical framework for representing uncertainty, in terms of dual measures of possibility and necessity. This leads to the existence of two kinds of possibilistic causal graphs where the conditioning is either based on the minimum, or the product operator. Benferhat et al. (1999) have investigated the connections between min-based graphs and possibilistic logic bases (made of classical formulas weighted in terms of certainty). This paper deals with a more difficult issue : the product-based graphical representations of possibilistic bases, which provides an easy structural reading of possibilistic bases. Moreover, this paper also provides another reading of possibilistic bases in terms of comparative preferences of the form "in the context p, q is preferred to not q". This enables us to explicit preferences underlying a set of goals with different levels of priority.
- Europe > France > Occitanie > Haute-Garonne > Toulouse (0.05)
- Europe > Netherlands > South Holland > Dordrecht (0.04)
- North America > United States > Colorado (0.04)
- (3 more...)
A possibilistic handling of partially ordered information
Benferhat, Salem, Lagrue, Sylvain, Papini, Odile
In a standard possibilistic logic, prioritized information are encoded by means of weighted knowledge base. This paper proposes an extension of possibilistic logic for dealing with partially ordered information. We Show that all basic notions of standard possibilitic logic (sumbsumption, syntactic and semantic inference, etc.) have natural couterparts when dealing with partially ordered information. We also propose an algorithm which computes possibilistic conclusions of a partial knowledge base of a partially ordered knowlege base.
- Europe > Netherlands > South Holland > Dordrecht (0.04)
- North America > United States > New York (0.04)
- Europe > United Kingdom > England > Oxfordshire > Oxford (0.04)
- Europe > France > Provence-Alpes-Côte d'Azur > Bouches-du-Rhône > Marseille (0.04)
Conflict-Based Belief Revision Operators in Possibilistic Logic
Qi, Guilin (Southeast University) | Wang, Kewen (Griffith University)
In this paper, we investigate belief revision in possibilistic logic, which is a weighted logic proposed to deal with incomplete and uncertain information. Existing revision operators in possibilistic logic are restricted in the sense that the input information can only be a formula instead of a possibilistic knowledge base which is a set of weighted formulas. To break this restriction, we consider weighted prime implicants of a possibilistic knowledge base and use them to define novel revision operators in possibilistic logic. Intuitively, a weighted prime implicant of a possibilistic knowledge base is a logically weakest possibilistic term (i.e., a set of weighted literals) that can entail the knowledge base. We first show that the existing definition of a weighted prime implicant is problematic and need a modification. To define a revision operator using weighted prime implicants, we face two problems. The first problem is that we need to define the notion of a conflict set between two weighted prime implicants of two possibilistic knowledge bases to achieve minimal change. The second problem is that we need to define the disjunction of possibilistic terms. We solve these problems and define two conflict-based revision operators in possibilistic logic. We then adapt the well-known postulates for revision proposed by Katsuno and Mendelzon and show that our revision operators satisfy four of the basic adapted postulates and satisfy two others in some special cases.
- Oceania > Australia (0.04)
- Asia > China (0.04)
- Europe > United Kingdom > England > Oxfordshire > Oxford (0.04)
Interval-Based Possibilistic Logic
Benferhat, Salem (Université) | Hué, Julien (Lille &ndash) | Lagrue, Sylvain (Nord de France, Artois and CRIL &ndash) | Rossit, Julien (CNRS UMR 8188)
Possibilistic logic is a well-known framework for dealing with uncertainty and reasoning under inconsistent knowledge bases. Standard possibilistic logic expressions are propositional logic formulas associated with positive real degrees belonging to [0,1]. However, in practice it may be difficult for an expert to provide exact degrees associated with formulas of a knowledge base. This paper proposes a flexible representation of uncertain information where the weights associated with formulas are in the form of intervals. We first study a framework for reasoning with interval-based possibilistic knowledge bases by extending main concepts of possibilistic logic such as the ones of necessity and possibility measures. We then provide a characterization of an interval-based possibilistic logic base by means of a concept of compatible standard possibilistic logic bases. We show that interval-based possibilistic logic extends possibilistic logic in the case where all intervals are singletons. Lastly, we provide computational complexity results of deriving plausible conclusions from interval-based possibilistic bases and we show that the flexibility in representing uncertain information is handled without extra computational costs.
On the Use of Guaranteed Possibility Measures in Possibilistic Networks
Ajroud, Amen (Universite de Sousse) | Benferhat, Salem (CRIL) | Omri, Mohamed Nazih (Universite de Sousse) | Youssef, Habib (Universite de Sousse)
Possibilistic networks are useful tools for reasoning under uncertainty. Uncertain pieces of information can be described by different measures: possibility measures, necessity measures and more recently, guaranteed possibility measures, denoted by Delta. This paper first proposes the use of guaranteed possibility measures to define a so-called Delta-based possibilistic network. This graphical representation tries to express and to deal with the minimal (lower-bound) possibility degree guaranteed for each variable. We then establish relationships between graphical and logical-based representations of uncertain information encoded by guaranteed possibility measures. We show that possibilistic networks based on guaranteed possibility measures can be easily transformed, in a polynomial time, in Delta-based knowledge bases. Then we analyze propagation algorithms in Delta-based possibilistic networks. In fact, standard possibilistic propagation algorithms can be re-used since we show that a simple rewriting of the chain rule allows the transformation of the initial Delta-based possibilistic networks into standard min-based possibilistic networks.
- Africa > Middle East > Tunisia > Sousse Governorate > Sousse (0.05)
- Asia > Middle East > Jordan (0.04)
- North America > United States > New York (0.04)
- (2 more...)